That slamming sound you hear is from the collective jaws of my readers hitting the ground after hearing me admit to once liking the oddball collection of studio outtakes
Garden in the City from Earth-mama songstress
Melanie. If you're unfamiliar with her work, she's the aural equivalent of a doe-eyed pastel-shaded
Margaret Keane painting.
I was introduced to her granola-infested oeuvre through a friendship with my high school's Freshman rebel. He seemed to abide alone (the parents he professed to live with were always away on mysterious "camping trips"), he sometimes smoked cigarettes and frequently got sent home from school for refusing to wear shoes. His unexplainable affection for this LP of boho folkie musings should have given me pause, but his outsider status amongst our age group drew me towards it all the more--it seemed to me just one more intoxicating swirl of icing on the iconoclast cake.
At the time, my alarming ignorance of rock history strengthened the assumption that
Don't You Wait By the Water was a vérité recording of purist backwoods blues and that
Lay Lady Lay was a Melanie original (after finally hearing
Dylan's "cover", its curious lack of flute freakout left me wanting). Listening to the painfully sincere
title track as an adult causes my eyebrows to arch ever upwards: why the freaky pronunciation of the word
country? How can you befriend a cloud? To paraphrase
Carla Bley's reaction to
The Shaggs: that song brings my mind to a complete halt.
Although
Garden in the City was not a chart-topping mega-hit, Melanie would later find fame via her soft-porn pop hit
Brand New Key, as well as renewed celebrity amongst indie hipsters after being recruited by
Stephen Merritt as a vocal guest of
The Sixths.
Garden's closing track (
People in the Front Row) cemented its place in the pop pantheon
after being sampled by Australian rap act Hilltop Hoods.
My shame over once favoring this musical transgression has never wavered. As soon as the
Rock and Roll Hall of Fame installs confessionals, I'll be the first one in line chirping my
Act of Contrition.